Showing posts with label testing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label testing. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

2/26/20 Report - Reading the Water to Find the Treasure Holes. Test Your Detector. Beach Privatization.


Written by the TreasureGuide for the exclusive use of treasurebeachesreport.blogspot.com.

Stairs at Seagrape Trail Saturday Morning.
Clipped form video submitted by DJ.

The posts at the bottom of the stairs at Seagrape Trail were getting washed out Saturday morning.  They had recently repaired them, but they were damaged again.  I was there that day but forgot to take photos.

Take a look at the stairs and the short posts sticking out of the sand in the photo below.  The posts are lower than the bottom step.  They weren't showing until the beach eroded.


Just To The North of the Seagrape Trail Access on 2/20
Clipped form video by DJ

Also notice the mass of water that is just below the stairs.  Just a few yards out is a wave surge behind that mass of water.  The surge will push the mass up the face of the slope, and the surge will rush up the slope towards the dunes.

Before I go much farther, I'd like to refer to what I think is the most important thing I've ever learned about beach dynamics.  The same principles apply to how things are moved in rivers and streams too, but for now I'm interested in these principles as they explain how sand and other items move on a beach.

Breaking it down, there is a certain amount of force needed to pick up different materials, including clay, silt, sand, pebbles, gravel and other items.  It takes more force to start an item moving than is required to keep the same item moving.

There is a certain amount of force required to suspend specific types of sand and other materials.  Generally it takes more water velocity and force to suspend clay than it takes to suspend sand, for example.  Even though the particles of clay are smaller, they are more cohesive so it takes more water force to pick it up.  And it takes more force to move pebbles than sand.  Things like the density of the objects, cohesiveness and even shape are important factors.  Pebbles are not more cohesive than sand, but they are more dense, so it takes more water velocity or force to get them moving.

There is also a certain amount of force required to keep an object moving once it is moving.  It takes less force to keep an object moving than it does to overcome the inertia and other factors that keep a particle or other object stationary.


The above chart shows velocity increasing from left to right on the horizontal axis, and particle size increasing from bottom to top on the vertical axis.  The right most red line shows that clay requires more force to suspend than sand, which requires less force to suspend than pebbles (or coins, rings, etc.).

Looking at the left most red line, you see that it takes little force to move already suspended clay or silt, but the force required to transport sand and pebbles or larger objects is greater.

Lets say you have enough water flow to get the sand moving, and enough to keep it moving, but then the force diminishes and the sand settles. The sand will be picked up where the force is relatively high, such as where the wave crashes, and carried up the slope until the water slows enough that the sand drops out of suspension.  If the water rushes back down the hill instead of slowly decreasing on the slope, sand can be carried down the hill, resulting in erosion.

The sand is moved when the force is great enough to pick it up and move it, and it is dropped when the force slows.  That part seems obvious enough, but there are other factors.  You have the tides and interacting multiple waves interacting.  Returning waves hit incoming waves, for example.  And there are irregularities in the surface of the beach.  And there is liquefaction.  (That is another topic for another time.)

There are different kinds of objects on the beach in addition to sand.  There are shells, and there might be coins and things.   Coins have their own peculiarities and methods of moving.  I once posted a number of ways that coins move.  But that is another discussion for another time.

Without getting into all the variables, sand will be moved differently than coins and things.  Different amounts of force are required to suspend and transport different objects.

Lets say you have just enough flow at the base of the slope to pick up and move sand.  It will be transported up the slope, and if the force slowly decreases, the sand will drop out and the sand will accumulate.   On the other hand, if the water picks up the sand and keeps it moving up the hill, and the water bounces off a cut or dune so the force is maintained at a high enough rate, the sand will wash down the hill again.  That is one way you get erosion.

Coins can be picked up if the force is great enough and carried up the hill along with the sand, but since it takes a greater amount of force to keep the denser objects moving, the water can slow enough to drop the coins while the sand continues to move out.  If the returning water force is great enough, the coins can be carried down the slope too.

You'll notice that when the water is bouncing off the face of a cut or off the dunes, the returning water can have a lot of force.  That means things will be carried down the slope until they drop out of suspension and settle in.

Different objects will settle at different places.  Like things will be dropped together.   As the water slows, coins and other things will drop out and settle before the sand.  That is how coin lines and coin holes are formed.   I've talked about that a lot in the past.

So what you are looking for is places where good targets have just been uncovered by eroding sand, or where those targets have been dropped.

After all of the fast moving water is over, slower water will move the grains of sand up the hill and drop the sand, building the beach and perhaps cover denser objects, such as any coins that were left behind.  Since you are interested in the areas where good targets are being uncovered or being dropped, you are looking for areas where the sand is being eroded or areas where the water has slowed enough to drop good targets.

It is all a beautiful balancing act.  Items are sifted and sorted like they are a gold pan, but on a beach the area is much bigger and there are a lot irregularities and complexities.  Still, I think you'll benefit if you get the ideas presented in the above chart.

...

PS: I lost the original source of the chart, so if anyone can find it I'd appreciate it.  I'd like to be able to credit the source.

---

I received some questions and know that some of you might be wondering if your detector might not be working ok because you didn't find anything good last weekend.   Your metal detector is probably fine.  If you are not sure, test it on some small silver coins.  Maybe cut an old silver dime in half, take it to the beach and test your metal detector.  If you can detect a small piece of silver like that, you can detect a silver reale unless it is too deep or something is wrong with your sweep.  So pay attention to your sweep speed and height when you do your tests.   It never hurts to take some test targets to the beach to make sure.  But I'd bet that your detector is fine.  There is a lot of beach out there and you just have to put your coil over the right spot at the right time.   If you understand what I wrote above, that will help you.  Finding the spots is the main thing.

I know how it is.  When you don't get any hits, you start to wonder if you detector is working well.  Usually it is, but you can test it to make sure.

---

Seems like there is some talk about beach privatization again.  I received the following emails from DJ.

Thought this bill died a couple years ago. 

HB 631 was approved and still on the books, lots of legaleaze



These bills are filed to repeal 631 and protect beach access for the public (as far as I can tell)




I’ll try to get more current info, they don’t make it easy to understand.



Hope we don’t have to face this too.

We had a petition going on this back some time ago.   Somebody needs to stay on top of this.

There is also some proposed legislation for the Florida Keys that the Fisher organization is fighting.  I've been meaning to post what I received about that, but there has been so much local news lately that I didn't get around to it yet.

---

The surf will be small this week.

Happy hunting,
Treasureguide@comcast.net











Saturday, July 7, 2018

7/7/18 Report - Hurricane Beryl. Marie Antoinette's Jewels. Magnet Uses. Stove Polish Bottle.


Written by the TreasureGuide for the exclusive use of treasurebeachesreport.blogspot.com.

Source: nhc.noaa.gov

The big news is the storm situation.  We have one system off of North Carolina and Hurricane Beryl out in the Atlantic

Its been a good while since we've had anything that might stir up the treasure beaches.  Its been several weeks of little but south winds and building beaches.

Here is the projected track of Beryl.

Source: nhc.noaa.gov
Notice that Beryl is now a hurricane but expected to turn into a storm by 2 PM Sunday as it heads in the direction of Cuba.

It looks like North Carolina is getting some north winds, but Ventusky is showing nothing but west and south winds for the Treasure Coast for the next week.

---

Source: Sothebys.com

Marie Antoinette's jewels
, not seen by the public for 200 years, will be auctioned by Sotheby's.



Click here to see a video of these and more of Marie Antoinette's jewels.

---

I've recently mentioned a few good uses for a magnet and wanted to remind you of a couple more.  I often get pictures of iron flakes that people find on the beach and wonder if they might be cobs.  You can use a magnet, and if they stick, the objects are not cobs.

Also many fakes will stick to a magnet.  A real silver reale or gold escudo will not stick.

Don't forget to try a magnet when you have those questions.

---

Stove Polish Bottle With Cork Inside.
Here is a nice bottle I found.  Almost all of my bottles are found on the Treasure Coast.  This one was found in a spring gully in West Virginia.  It is really nice and clean.

Here is one little detail that I like about it.

Glass Gouge and Lump Made While Glass Was Still Soft.
In this photo you can see where a gouge was made in the glass while it was still hot and soft.  To the left of that you can see a lump of glass when the hot glass from the gouge was dropped.

It looks like the glass blower or his assistant made a little mistake.  It is a reminder of how the bottle was made, and like errors on coins, helps you understand and appreciate the process.

---

The surf is calm this morning, but like I said yesterday, it is the time of year to watch for storms.  You don't want to miss any long-awaited window of opportunity.

Happy hunting,
TreasureGuide@comcast.net



Saturday, March 10, 2018

3/10/18 Report - Experimenting To Learn More About Your Detector. A Tale of Three Different One-Cent Coins.


Written by the TreasureGuide for the exclusive use of treasurebeachesreport.blogspot.com.

Here is a little demonstration using three one-cent coins and a Garrett Ace 250.  In the video I'll pass the coil over each of the three one-cent pieces so you can hear the signal.  See what you can tell from the signal.  The coins are on the surface so you can see them, although you probably can't make them out.



The first coin had a stable bell tone.  On the Ace, that indicates a coin and the meter read penny.

On the second, the signal varied from pass to pass and the meter sometimes read dime and sometimes junk.

On the third coin, the target was consistent and the meter read iron.

Can you guess why the detector reacted that way?
,
The first target was a modern zinc penny.  It sounded like a coin and the meter showed it as a penny.  Nothing surprising there.

The second target was very inconsistent, giving two types of signal, and sometimes showed as iron on the meter and sometimes as a dime.

The third target, was a U. S. penny, but sounded like iron and showed on the meter as iron.  That target was a 1943 steel penny.

So what about the second target?  This one was a little tricky.  It was a euro one-cent piece, which is copper coated steel.

The Ace 250 is an inexpensive detector, but in my opinion works well for the money, but sometimes coins are not easy to identify.  Many are made of more than one type of metal.  Even a regular Lincoln penny is only 95% copper. And a regular zinc penny is only 97.5 percent zinc, with a thin copper coating.  Much of the time you can identify a type of coin from the meter or digital output, but sometimes it is more complicated, especially when you get into world coins.

It might seem that the Ace did a poor job, however I think it did pretty well.  The first target was identified as coin-like, the third as iron, and the second sounded very much like the combination that it actually was.

My main point is not what the Ace does.  It is just one example.  The bigger point that I want to make is the value of conducting experiments in order to get to better know what your detector is trying to tell you.

I always highly recommend experimenting with your detector and a variety of types of targets.  Often the more interesting targets are not simple to identify from the detector output.

When I get a new detector I do a lot of testing.  I might use the manual as a starting place, but I don't accept much of what the manual says without testing it out.  I like to test a detector in various modes and using various settings on a variety of types of targets and different types of environments.

I recommend not only testing your detector at the beginning, but continuing to test it as long as you use it.  You'll continue to learn about how your detector responds to various types of targets in different situations.

Someone might be very disappointed to learn that their detector wouldn't always correctly identify a penny, but there are different types of pennies, and there are other things that will affect the detectors ability to identify targets.

One big problem with relying too much on target ID I already referred to.  The most interesting targets are often not common targets and that can make it risky to go entirely by your detector's ID meter.  If you want to know if a target is a dime or quarter, most detector's will do that pretty well, however when you get into watches or other more complex targets, you'll need to use your own brain more.  I did a video or two in the past showing how a couple detectors responded to various watches.  I bet a lot of Rolex or other high-end watches are passed over simply because the detector ID didn't identify the target well enough.

In pinpoint mode many detectors give a lot of information on a target.  You can get a good idea of depth and size without referring to anything other than the signal if you spend enough time learning.

There are other factors that will help you with target ID that requires using your brain and assessing the entire situation.  Some types of targets will be in certain areas and at certain depths, for example.

There is no substitute for careful observation and experimentation.

Experience doesn't guarantee expertise, but it does make it more likely.

---

I still haven't been out again yet.  I'd like to get some recent reports.

The tides are now small.  The surf is down to around three or four feet. And the wind is from the south tomorrow.  None of those things are encouraging.c

Happy hunting,
TreasureGuide@comcast.net




Tuesday, October 7, 2014

10/7/14 Report - The Experimental Method Applied to Metal Detecting. Adaptability For Optimal Detecting Anywhere.


Written by the TreasureGuide for the exclusive use of treasurebeachesreport.BlogSpot.com.

Small 10K Ring Find.
If you are always going to hunt in the same places with the same detector looking for the same types of targets that is fine, but the probability is that you are not always going to be doing the same thing all the time.  And if you are not going to be doing the same thing all the time, you need to know how to adapt.

A few days ago I did a poll and asked people where they hunted "most."  You probably read the results, yet there were several different locations mentioned in that little poll.  Like some, you might hunt on an ocean beach in the wet sand "most" of the time, but there are probably also times when you hunt in the dry sand or inland, or whatever.  That means that you will need to know how to adapt.

If you want to be able to adapt, you can't just set your detector's settings the same every time and expect to get the best results.  A day or two ago I told you how important the threshold setting could be on a PI detector.  There was a threshold level that produced the best signal.   Either too high or two low could cause you to completely miss a thin gold ring.

You need to use the best settings for each environment.  And you can't always take some one's specific instructions and simply apply them.  Their situation might not be the same as yours in some small but important way.

The point is to know how to determine your best settings, best detector selection, and best hunting techniques where ever you might be and what ever you might be hunting.

I use a method that I've called "empirical."  That means basically that it is based upon data that comes from skeptical observation.  I could also refer to my method as "scientific," even though it is not highly controlled as it would be in a laboratory setting. 

I continually conduct experiments.  You might remember the experiments I conducted to see how objects sink in sand.  Those posts were two that were the most "google plused" of any that I have done.

You might remember the experiments I did to determine how objects of different sizes and shapes moved in water.  Those are just two quick examples.

I also apply "test it" and "prove it" method when selecting my detector settings at the beginning of a hunt.  That does several things for me besides checking for the optimal settings for the particular type of target that I am most interested in finding.

I won't take it for granted that the optimal setting will be what it was last time or at another beach or when hunting something else. 

There are a lot of little things that can make a big difference.  Is there black sand today?  Is the sand rippled or smooth?  Is there radio interference or EMI?  

The beaches in South Florida are very different than those on the Treasure Coast.  I began detecting when I lived in South Florida and later moved to the Treasure Coast.  It is a big difference.  It is necessary to adapt.

Recently I reported on some experiments with the Ace 250 and Whites Dual Field Surf PI detectors.  I told you what I learned from my experiments, but the most important thing was not the results.  The most important thing was the method the method that I used to determine the best settings. 

You can pretty much use most of the same settings most of the time if you do hunt the same places and hunt for the same things in the same way all of the time, but there are still advantages of going through the method of testing with relevant test targets.  For one thing, it will give you advanced warning of deterioration in detector performance.  That is just one of several good reasons to go through the process.

The method that I used to tune my PI for gold, for example, employed a relevant test target and a systematic procedure at the location I was preparing to hunt.  The same method could be used at different locations with different detectors and targets, and the procedure would work just as well.

My point is not that there are important differences in beaches and detectors and targets.  Everybody knows that.  My point is that you can't take specific settings and set your detector the same way in every situation and expect optimal results.  That is one reason that I was not more specific about exactly where to set the gain and threshold when I did my test.  What I gave you was something better - a method of finding the best setting for yourself no matter where you are going to hunt and what types of things you want to find.

My "empirical" or "experimental" method has been applied to a lot of different things, not just tuning a detector.  I was a researcher for many years and brought that same experimental approach to my detecting.  I didn't accept what someone else said, but experimented and proved or disproved things for myself.

My experimental method not only applies to detectors and settings, but to almost everything that I do in metal detecting.  As I said above, I've done experiments on how objects sink in sand, for example, and how different types of objects are moved by waves, as another example.

I still continue to learn.  Some of my most valuable experiments showed that something that I believed was wrong.  That is when you have to figure it out and make a change.

What I'm telling you today is something that was in my posts, but which I have not made crystal clear.  The important thing that I'm giving you is an approach.  I am giving you a method of learning, not just specific information to memorize and apply.  


The surf on the Treasure Coast will be around two to three feet for a couple days.  It will slowly increase for a few days after that.

There is nothing in the Atlantic to watch.

Happy hunting,
TreasureGuide@Comcast.net